Author Archives: Dennis D. Chamberlain

E12- Israel Proctor and the Murder of Thomas Chamberlain

Thomas Chamberlain was murdered on May 11, 1709. The circumstances of this crime were unknown in the modern age until FamilySearch filmed the court records in 1972. More recently, the perpetrator was exposed and graphic details of this event revealed when introduced on the world wide web.1 The killer was Israel Proctor.

Thomas Chamberlain III

Thomas Chamberlain III was born May 30, 1667 in Chelmsford, Massachusetts. He was the first son of Thomas born in 1639 and the first grandson of Thomas the immigrant who arrived in Virginia in 1635.2 His mother was Sarah Proctor the daughter of Robert Proctor and Jane Hildreth.3

When Thomas was 8 years old, his father was stationed at the garrison in Groton, during the King Phillips Indian war, and served in Captain Joseph Sills expedition to Osipee and Pequawket in September, 1676.4

In September of 1691, Indians raided Dunstable. Thomas, his father, and brother Samuel, therefore, began rendering services in the garrison at Chelmsford to protect the town in 1692. Also that year, nearby communities were in turmoil due to the witch trials inflicted upon them. This nightmare affected many residents including members of the Chamberlain family.

Thomas married Elizabeth Heald  January 9, 1690 and they lived in Chelmsford, Massachusetts. Their first child, John, was born on March 29,1692. Five more children, Joseph, Aaron, Moses, Gershom, and Sarah, soon followed.

Thomas Chamberlain’s Mill

Thomas was a wheelwright and a miller by occupation.  On March 10, 1699, he bought a 50 acre farm and a mill at “Baddacook” by Brown Loaf Hill in the town of Groton, Massachusetts2  Later events would one day make the Chamberlain mill location an historical landmark.

A. Chamberlain Mill location at confluence of Martins Pond Brook and Paugus Brook. B. Location of Chamberlain Mill historical marker, Hwy 40, and Lost Lake Drive. C. School House Road and Chamberlains Mill Lane, Groton, Massachusetts.

Thomas’ second wife

Elizabeth Chamberlain died at Groton on June 18, 1699, two of their children also died that year. Thomas’s children were all under the age of 8. Two months later on August 16, he married his second wife Abigail Nutting.

Over the next ten years Thomas and Abigail added seven more children to the clan, Elisabeth, Abigail, Thomas, Mary, Jane, Dorothy and Sarah.2,3

On May 11, 1709, there were ten children living in the Chamberlain home and Abigail was expecting another daughter. Sarah was born three months after the death of her father.

Israel Proctor

Israel Proctor was born April 29, 1668. He was the tenth child of his parents Robert Proctor and Jane Hildreth. In 1689, he married his first cousin, Margaret Hildreth. They had two children Lidiah in 1690, and Josiah in 16915 Margaret died in 1693.6

Israel’s oldest sister, Sarah Proctor, was Thomas’ mother. Therefore, Israel was Thomas’ uncle. They were, however, about the same age. Though Israel was eleven months younger than Thomas, on the date of the crime both men were 41 years old.

Thomas was a husbandman for Israel at Chelmsford, apparently taking care of his farm at that location.1 Many of the Chamberlain family still lived in Chelmsford. Thomas, however, moved to Groton more than ten years previous where he ran his mill.

Murder at Chamberlain Mill

It is believed the murder took place at the Chamberlain mill in Groton, though I have not been able to verify this information.7

It is hard to imagine the situation that would precipitate the events of May 11, 1709. A group of eight men were together that day, presumably at the mill. Samuel Barnes and Isaac Barnes testified that at the time they departed for home, there was peace among the two men. The other four men, John Read, Sam Chamberlain, Joseph Chamberlain and Timothy Adams were listed in the record as witnesses.8

In July, 1709 in the Court at Cambridge Massachusetts, the jury found that “Israel Proctor feloniously and willfully murdered the said Thomas Chamberlain”. This was done with several stabs or strokes of a bayonet or short sword to the body of Chamberlain, on or near the groin right side. The fatal stab “entering so far into the body of the said Thomas Chamberlain that he then and there died instantly of said wound or wounds”1

The court record lists no motive for the brutal crime. However, they determined malice aforethought, a conscious intent to cause death before the crime, or an evil and depraved state of mind with no concern for the lives of others. “Israel Proctor… not having the fear of God before his eyes but being instigated by the devil and of his malice forethought”.1

An unusual sentence

The court found Israel Proctor guilty of manslaughter. He was then tied to the gallows for one hour with a rope around his neck. They then took him down and sentenced him to receive thirty stripes upon his naked body, while being tied to a cart’s tail. The court also ordered him to pay compensation to widow Chamberlain for her support. Abigail Chamberlain, at the time, had eleven minor children.8

Israel Proctor died at Chelmsford on June 9, 1755. He was 87 years old.

Thomas Chamberlain’s estate

John Heald of Concord, brother of Thomas’ first wife Sarah, took inventory of the estate. He was appointed guardian to Thomas’ oldest son, John “a minor in ye 18th year of his age.”9

On June 30, 1713, after John reached his majority, the court settled his father’s estate. They allotted one third to the widow Abigail Chamberlain.  John inherited two thirds of his father’s mill, housing, stream, and lands in Groton. This was on the condition of paying to each of the other children 2 Pounds, 17 Shillings, and 6 2/3 pence, a value equivalent in 2021 of about $225 to each of his ten living siblings.

Paugus John Chamberlain

John Chamberlain and Chief Paugus duel at Lovewell’s Pond

In 1725, John was among 47 men of Captain John Lovewell’s expedition to engage the Indians at their headquarters at Pigwacket. Chief Paugus had come from a distant tribe to lead the local Indians in attacks on nearby villages. At the battle at Lovewell’s Pond John Chamberlain distinguished himself with a face to face duel with the Indian Chief. John won the duel by a fraction of a second.

Lovewell’s men were out numbered and surrounded. The death of Paugus likely saved the majority of Lovewell’s men, because, after the duel, the Indian band fled the scene. John became an instant hero in Groton, Massachusetts where he became known as Paugus John Chamberlain.

His fame spread far and wide, but after many years, some questioned the story. The Chamberlain Story presents the facts in the case for John Chamberlain in The Legend of Paugus John Chamberlain

Chamberlain mill memorial rock

In the fall, the son of Paugus came looking for John Chamberlain in Groton to avenge the death of his father. A neighbor warned John about the possible attack. The showdown took place at the mill that John inherited from his father.

The mill was situated on Martin’s Pond Brook about 200 yards South of present day (2021) Highway 40 and east of Brown Loaf. In 1883, the location was near School House 9 near the confluence of  Martin’s Pond Brook and a small stream called Paugus Brook.10

In 1951, the City of Groton engraved a rock to point out the historical site of the Chamberlain mill. The memorial is in a grove of trees south of Hwy 40, and west Lost Lake Road. Today (2021) there is also a Chamberlain’s Mill Lane which enters on to School House Road. This is north of Hwy 40. Brown Loaf Hill is south of Highway 40 near this location, which is about one mile east of Groton town center.

Chamberlain Mill Memorial Rock- Lowell Rd (Route 40), west of Lost Lake Drive. Thomas Chamberlain bought the mill in 1699. According to legend, his son, John Chamberlain, killed the son of Chief Paugus in self-defense at this location. Presented by the Groton Historical Society on April 10th 1951 (Photo by Jonathan Pierce 5/12/2019)

Court record of the trial of Israel Proctor

FamilySearch photographed and recorded this record in 1972. More recently, someone found it and placed it on the internet.1

Suffolk County Court File Vol. 77, Item 7783

Translation into modern English

Middlesex Se: At court of Assize and General goal. Delivery holden at Cambridge for the County the last Tuesday of July 1709.

The Jurors of our Sovereign Lady, the Queen upon their oaths of present Israel Procter of Chelmsford, within the County of Middlesex, husbandman for that said Israel Proctor at Chelmsford, afore said on the eleventh day of May last, not having the fear of God before his eyes, but being instigated by the Devil and of his malice aforethought with force and arms, and against the peace, an assault made on the body of Thomas Chamberlain of Groton afore said miller. Then in the peace of God of the Queen, being and with a bayonet or short sword of the value of five shillings, he the said Israel Proctor feloniously made several mortal stabs or strokes on the body of the said Tho. Chamberlain, viz. on or near the groin, ye right side, the bayonet or short sword entering so far into the body of the said Thomas Chamberlain that he then and there instantly died of the said wound or wounds, and so the Jurors, afore said say that the afore said Israel Proctor feloniously and willfully murdered the said Thomas Chamberlain against the peace of our Sovereign Lady the Queen, her crown and dignity and the law.1

Witnesses: John Read, Sam Chamberlain, Joseph Chamberlain, Timothy Adams.  Abraham Durant Governor.1

© Copyright Dennis D. Chamberlain, All rights reserved. The Chamberlain Story, 2021.

References:

1- FamilySearch, Suffolk County Court: File #7783, (Family Search)

2-George W. Chamberlain, One Branch of the Descendants of Thomas Chamberlain of Woburn, Worcester Mass, 1897

3-Chamberlain Family-The First Six Generations, http://www.babcockancestry.com/

4- William Hubbard, Indian Wars in New England, Roxbury, Mass, MDCCCXV.

5- A genealogy of descendants of Robert Proctor of Concord and Chelmsford, Mass., Robert Proctor (p.5), Israel Proctor (p.8)

6- Familysearch.org

7- Thomas of Woburn, Third Generation by David C. Chamberlain, www.chamberlain.society.org

8- Steve Dow, My New England Ancestors, The Murder of Thomas Chamberlain, 3-11-2018, Court Record #7713 (warrant for holding Proctor in jail), #25013 (bill of constable Jonathan Hill of Chelmsford, who arrested and delivered Proctor), #27946 (Barnes testimony),  #28051 (testimony on a piece of neckcloth) Superior Court of Judicature, 1700-1714 (film 945843): pages 239-240 (Family Search)

9- George W. Chamberlain, B. S., John Chamberlain, the Indian Fighter at Pigwacket, Reprint from Quarterly of the Maine Historical Society, Jan., 1898.

10- Samuel A. Green, M. D., Groton During the Indian Wars, Groton Mass., 1883

E11- Dad’s Hope for Our Best Christmas Ever, 1942

Ernest, Fay, Martin and Dennis Chamberlain, Olympia, Washington, May 6, 1942

I was born in 1942 during the war. My dad and mother desperately wanted our family to be together that year for Christmas. If we are still together in December, dad promised, it will be our best Christmas ever.

My father, Lt. Ernest M. Chamberlain, left for Fort Lewis, Washington on December 31, 1941. My mother, Agnes Fay Barney Chamberlain, and my brother Martin moved in to her parent’s home in Salt Lake City. Dennis Chamberlain (aka me) became part of the Chamberlain family in March.

Ernest and Fay Chamberlain wrote to each other almost every day during World War 2. Fay saved every personal letter and card she ever received. She therefore preserved the story of our family during the war.

The World in March 1942

The world was not a very inviting place in March 1942. Nevertheless, I had been invited and was on my way. Gratefully, my destination was the USA, and to loving parents Ernest and Fay Chamberlain, and to the peaceful home of my grandparents, Archie and Livonia Barney.

HMS Exeter fighting off aircraft attack in 1942

In March 1942 the world was a mess and our freedom was in serious peril. The Imperial Empire of Japan scored a major victory in the naval battle of Java Sea, and they were well on their way to occupy all of Dutch East India, (Indonesia). They surrounded the Philippines. General Douglass MacArthur narrowly escaped with his family and staff. In Australia he declared, “I shall return.”

A German submarine near Cuba torpedoed and sank the USS Texan an American Cargo Ship. At Riga, in Nazi occupied Latvia, 3740 men, women and children (Jews, Gypsies and those who opposed the occupation) were taken into the nearby woods and shot.1

This was the state of the world when I arrived.

The day I was born

One morning in March 1942 Fay Chamberlain opened the trap door in the bathroom floor and dumped the laundry through the hole. It fell into a basket on the floor in the basement. “At nine am”, she wrote in a letter to her husband, “the pains started and were every ten minutes apart. I went down and did the washing without telling anyone about them.2

The washing machine hummed a soothing rhythm as the clothing swished back and forth. She took the clothes out of the water, placed them piece by piece through the ringer, then pinned them on the line to dry.

In her letter she continued: “By 11:00 the pains were quite hard and I decided I might as well tell them and get it over with.” Fay did not like to be the center of attention, especially during times of distress. Therefore, she always understated her pain and discomfort. “The pain got pretty good and I called the Doctor. He said ‘Go to the hospital Immediately!”2

Her pains were now 4 minutes apart.

Her father, Archie Barney, came home from work and got her and Livonia and they where on their way. There was one minor detour. Fay had to stop at the Bank in downtown Salt Lake to get money to pay the hospital. “So Dad took me to the bank to get the money. Wasn’t I crazy? I could have had it on Main Street! I hadn’t told them how hard they were and Mom and Dad figured there was plenty of time. We got to the hospital at 2:30”2

Archie and Livonia were unaware they were carrying a ticking time bomb. Fay preferred they were not present for the main event. So she told them everything was fine and sent them into town to run their errands. “Just as they left the room the water broke.” She called the nurse at 3:10 and at 3:15 she was in the delivery room.2

I arrived on the scene at 4:02 pm.

“Mom was sure mad when she got back… She was happy it was over but mad at me for sending her away.” Fay wrote to Ernest.

Archie wrote in his journal with a hint of disgust: “Fay told us to take our time not hurry. The baby boy was born between 3:30 and 4:00 pm while Livonia and I were at Z.C.M.I.”3

Our first family reunion, May 1, 1942

Ernest was lonely, especially on weekends. He wished Fay was there so he could take her to the occasional big dance party in town for the officers.

On April 8 Fay wrote: “I’m getting anxious and excited about coming up now. I am frightened every time the phone rings and it is for Mrs. E. M. Chamberlain. I’m afraid you are calling to say good bye. I don’t think I could stand it if I didn’t get to see you, and have you see your sons before they grow up too much.”4

Ernest wrote on April 12: “Let’s throw caution to the winds… If we gamble and I see you for but a moment, no money was ever spent better.”5

Ernest found a vacancy at the Holly Auto Court on the main highway about two miles east of Olympia Washington. Our plane left Salt Lake City on May 1 and we met Dad at the Seattle airport. It was wonderful to be together for the first time as a family of four.

Long Days for Fay

After three weeks together, Ernest had to leave Fay and us boys in the motor court. Three days later, Fay wrote:

“These have been the longest three days. I don’t know what the next two weeks will be like. Maybe if the sun would shine it would help, huh?”6

She complained that It rains whenever she puts the clothes on the line and soaks them.

Finally, Ernest returned on about June 15th. They were happy to be together for their fourth wedding anniversary on June 29.

However, Ernest soon received orders to take a Communications Course at Fort Sill, Oklahoma. The course was TD (temporary duty) and would terminate in about three months. Upon completion he would return to Fort Lewis, Washington.7

Our family left Washington and we arrived in Salt Lake City at Fay’s parent’s home about August 24th.

Martin, Ernest, Fay, Dennis Chamberlain, Livonia & Carol Barney, Alden Street home, August 1942

Fort Sill, Oklahoma August 29, 1942

Ernest left us behind in Salt Lake with great hopes to get together soon. His train arrived at Fort Sill on August 29. He studied hard on his classes which included electricity, map reading, telephone, radio and secret codes and Morse Code.8

1941 Plymouth 2 Door Sedan

He missed his family and was counting the days until they would be together again. However, Martin needed to have his to tonsils out in Salt Lake. Also, Ernest wanted to buy their first car. This would solve some problems, but cash would be tight for a while.8

Big plans for Christmas

Fay was excited about the car and wanted to see pictures and know more about it. Hopefully, she could meet Ernest in Oklahoma, and at least come back with him. “When am I coming to see you?” she wrote. However, this dream was fading. The car down payment, insurance and $50 monthly payments, caused them to reconsider their plans to get together at Fort Sill.

“The money alone is not important, Ernest wrote, but the fact that to get to Fort Lewis will probably take all or more than we can save up and after we get there it will be December. I want this Christmas, if we are still able to be together, the best we have ever had”.8

The big day finally arrived and on Friday November 20, Ernest graduated from the army Communications Course. The next morning he went to the ration board to get a little extra gas and bade goodbye to old Fort Sill. He arrived in Salt Lake City about November 23.

Preparing for Christmas in Olympia, Washington

After their brief visit in Salt Lake, they loaded Fay’s sewing machine and supplies into the car. She was an excellent seamstress and liked to modify her own clothes and planned to make Christmas clothes for the children. She was delighted the family was together and that she would have something she enjoyed doing when Ernest was away.

When they arrived in Olympia, they found a motel along the highway near Fort Lewis. They decorated it and fixed it up. Fay was happy about her new home and sewing set up. Ernest was excited about Christmas. It was now only a few weeks away.

Fay’s Ft. Lewis ID Badge

On Tuesday, December 8, Fay drove Ernest to Fort Lewis.  He wanted to be sure she learned the route so she could get back to the motel. Ernest watched as Fay, Martin and Dennis traveled two blocks and turned onto the highway.9

Ernest then walked up the stairs to headquarters, but found the building vacant except for two enlisted men. They told him his unit was training at the firing range in Yakima, Washington on the other side of the mountain.9 “Get on the kitchen truck, it is leaving in a few minutes!”10

He had told Fay he would be back for dinner, but instead he was now heading for the firing range in Yakama.9 

It gets worse

Early the next morning Ernest was at a train station in Billings Montana frantically writing to Fay.  He knew she would be upset. He had to explain to her his incredible experiences of the last 24 hours, and why he didn’t call her sooner.

“Here is my story”, he wrote at 3 am, “I haven’t really had any sleep since I last saw you”.11

He told her he had to leave for Yakima, “We finally managed to leave at 9:20 am”.

The trip should take about four hours. However, due to heavy rain and snow and an over turned gasoline trailer, the 180-mile trip around Mt. Rainier took 12 hours. They arrived at 9:30 pm.11

When Ernest got to Yakima, he walked into the adjutant’s tent to report in. The adjutant looked at him and said, “Aren’t you at Fort Sill?”11

Obviously, he was not.

“I just came from Fort Sill. I finished my course there and returned to my permanent station”, Ernest replied.10,11

“We sent your orders to Fort Sill, didn’t you get our telegram?” They told Ernest that he is supposed to take another three month course at Fort Sill since he is already there. “School starts tomorrow morning, December 9, the soonest you can possibly get there is the 10th. You need to be on the next train to Fort Sill!”11

Poor Ernest was a day late and $60.00 dollars short, for he had no money to buy his train ticket. When they got to the train station, Union Pacific had just left. Northern Pacific took a longer route, but now would arrive sooner. “Finally, miracle of miracles, I found a fellow that would take my check for $60.00.” he wrote. He then bought his ticket on NP.11

What else can go wrong?

Ernest felt sick. It would have been just as easy to make the trip with the family back to Ft. Sill, Oklahoma as it was to go to Ft. Lewis, Washington.

Suddenly it dawned on Ernest that it was after 10 o’clock and Fay was waiting for him back in the motel in Olympia. And now, he was about to board a train for Oklahoma. Not only that, he didn’t know the phone number of the motel!10,11

He looked through the phone directory. There was no listing for Hi Way Motor Court or the manager’s name Rowe. In desperation Ernest called the Switchboard in Olympia Washington. At that time, live operators conducted all telephone service. The operator was very patient and accommodating and connected him with the Highway Patrol. They read Ernest the long list of motels found between Fort Lewis and Olympia. None of them sounded familiar.10,12

Ernest got the same operator back and she graciously began calling each of the motels along the highway to see if they had a Mrs. Chamberlain registered there. Finally, one manager told her that the Hi Way Motor Court might be listed under the name “Gibson”. And it was. They recently changed the name.10,11

He called the number and the manager, Mr. Rowe answered. He confirmed that Mrs. Chamberlain was indeed registered there.10,11

Where is Fay?

Ernest told Mr. Rowe he needed to talk to Mrs. Chamberlain. So, Mr. Rowe went and knocked on the door. He came back to the phone and told Ernest: “Mrs. Chamberlain is not home. The car is there, but the newspaper has not been taken in.11

Ernest said: “Please give her a message as soon as you see her. Tell her I am on my way to Fort Sill and won’t return.” He then rushed off to catch the train.10

As he boarded the train his mind was whirling. “Where is Fay?” He worried about all the possibilities. “Had she gotten back from the post OK? Was he sure her car was there? If that was our car, why wasn’t she home?”11

Billings Montana, December 9, 1942

Postcard and Letter mailed from Billings, Montana, December 9, 1942 5 am and 5 pm

The Northern Pacific train pulled in to Billings Montana at about 3 am. It was over one hour behind schedule, so he missed his connection with the train to Kansas City. The next train would not leave for seven hours.11

He immediately started writing to Fay. He wrote a quick note on a post card and mailed it before the morning pick-up. The post card note read:

Dearest Fay – I certainly have felt punk today worrying about you and thinking of how I messed up X-mas. Write me by airmail what you plan to do. Will send you complete letter soon as possible. Love, Ernest.13

He then composed a six page letter with the woeful details of his day. Since he missed the connection to Kansas City, he boarded the next train to Lincoln, Nebraska. The train finally left Billings, Montana and chugged its way to Lincoln where he missed his connection again.14

Abandoned at Hi Way Motor Court

The manger told Fay the message from Ernest the next morning. Last night she was exhausted and didn’t wake up when the manger knocked on the door. The paper on the porch was some free advertisements which she ignored.12

When she got the message she felt angry and abandoned. “I don’t know whether I’m more homesick, lonesome or plain scared, but the combination leaves my quite ill”, she wrote in her letter to Ernest.15

Fay spent that afternoon at the rationing board to see if she can get gas. And tomorrow she had to go to the fort to get authorization from some Colonel. “I’m using up all my gas trying to get more gas. If I do get the gas how will I get home?15

Fay had very little driving experience and driving alone with two small children was not an option.

Her mind was full of questions: How much money is in the checking account? Should she stay here? or go to Salt Lake? or go to Fort Sill? And how would she get there? Should she take a train and store the car in Washington? Would Ernest ever return to Fort Lewis?15

Fay was much happier the next day after she received the post card. She wrote on December 11: “Dearest Ernest. Hello again. How did you like the scorcher you received previous? I hope this one will not be quite as bad. Anyway I was happy to receive your card and am looking forward to the letter. Hope it is soon.”15

Dean Barney to the rescue, December 14, 1942

Fay called her folks in Salt Lake City. The long-distance call was $3.00 (about $44 in 2020). “Isn’t that terrible”, she wrote. However, she was pleasantly surprised that her call went through so quickly. It took only 45 minutes.15

She told her family her sad story and her seventeen-year-old brother Dean Barney said, “I will come up.”10

Fay, Martin and Dennis were soon on their way back to the home of Archie and Livonia Barney.

Ernest back at Fort Sill

Plans can change fast when there is a war going on and you are in the service of your country. Only three weeks ago Ernest was leaving this post and well on his way to filling his dream of “our best Christmas ever”. Now he is back at Fort Sill.

By December 16, Ernest was at his wits end and mad at the world. This was the day he received Fay’s self described “scorcher.” He flunked his first test that day, but he was especially frustrated with the many futile attempts and hours he had spent trying to contact Fay. Also, the mail back and forth took so long that the situation would change. For example, by the time Ernest was upset and responding to her letter of December 10, Fay was at home in Salt Lake and the crisis was over.

Later that day he wrote Fay another letter. “Sorry I sent the last letter” he said. “I was just trying so hard to be able to be with you and the boys for Christmas.” He was especially counting on watching Martin open his presents on Christmas morning.14

Fay was also very disappointed that their plans for Christmas didn’t work out:  “Every time I think of how we all have to be separated, I just wilt inside. We try so hard to be together and have what family life we can. Dennis was just beginning again to love his Dad and Martin misses you so much”.15

Ernest and Fay made urgent plans to get together at Fort Sill after the first of the year. Rumors abound, and the latest was that they would be sent overseas for the Spring 1943 offensive before Ernest even finished the course.

Christmas day December 25, 1942

While disappointed they were not together for Christmas, they also recognized their blessings. “I am happy knowing you are at least near and not “over there”, Fay wrote.15

Fay, Martin and Dennis spent a wonderful Christmas with Granddad and Grandma Barney. While Ernest went to a movie, “The Black Swan”, one which they had hoped to see together.

Barney/Chamberlain Christmas 1942

On Christmas Eve, Ernest wrote to Fay the following note expressing gratitude and hope for the future:

Here I am really not so far away, and above all whether I am far or near I have been granted the privilege of having three beautiful hearts tucked away safely in my bosom. And soon, God granting, I can have them all so very near to me. When the war is all over and Christmas comes around again that star on top the tree will really look like the Star of Bethlehem and truly shine out ‘Peace on earth, good will to men’. Then we can make up for what we miss now.- Love Ernest, December 24, 1942.14

Three years later

That star of hope will finally shine on the Chamberlain Christmas tree three years later. On that  magical night in 1945, Martin and I were sure we heard reindeer on the roof and couldn’t wait for morning. The war was over. Dad came home and the family is now together.

I still remember this year as our best Christmas ever.

The rest of the story….

Read the full story of Ernest and Fay Chamberlain in 1942. Chapter 29- Ernest and Fay Chamberlain During WWII 1942  and the author’s memories of 1943 to 1948 including Christmas 1945. Chapter 30- Dennis Chamberlain, Family and Early Memories During WWII

Acknowledgments:

Thanks to Deanna Chamberlain Grant for publishing “Selected Journals of Archie Fay Barney” and DVD with the photos to make this information available. And to Lyle Brent Chamberlain for his 1984 interview with Fay and Ernest Chamberlain on DVD. And of course to Archie F. Barney, Ernest M. Chamberlain and Fay Barney Chamberlain for writing down and preserving this information.

© Copyright Dennis D. Chamberlain, The Chamberlain Story, 2020. Unauthorized use and/or duplication of the written content of this site without express and written permission from the author and owner is strictly prohibited. Excerpts and links may be used, provided that credit is given to Dennis D. Chamberlain and direction to  www.thechamberlainstory.com.

References:

1- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/March_1942

2- Fay Barney Chamberlain, Letters to husband Ernest M. Chamberlain, March 1942.

3- Archie F. Barney, Journal entry for March 1942.

4- Fay Barney Chamberlain, Letter to her husband Ernest M. Chamberlain, written April 8, 1942

5- Ernest M. Chamberlain, Letter to his wife Fay Barney Chamberlain, written April 12, 1942

6- Fay Barney Chamberlain, Letters to Ernest M. Chamberlain, April 25 through May, 1942

7- Orders from Headquarters IX Army Corps, Fort Lewis, Wash, 17 Aug 1942

8- Ernest M. Chamberlain, Letters to Salt Lake from Fort Sill, Aug 29- Nov 18, 1942

9- Ernest M. Chamberlain, “What More Can Happen” presentation given to seniors and family on July 5, 2012.

10- Ernest & Fay Chamberlain Personal Histories, Recorded 25 June 1984 in England by Lyle Brent Chamberlain.

11- Ernest M. Chamberlain, Letter to Mrs. E. M. Chamberlain, “Hi-Way Motor Court (Located on Highway between Ft Lewis and Olympia), Olympia Washington”. Postmark: Billings Mont. Dec 9, 1942 5 PM

12- Ernest Martin Chamberlain, Jr. Ernest Chamberlain’s Early Army Years, written November, 2001.

13- Ernest M. Chamberlain, Post Card to Mrs. E. M. Chamberlain, “Hi-Way Motor Court (Located on Highway between Ft Lewis and Olympia), Olympia Washington.” Postmark: Billings Mont. Dec 9, 1942 5 AM

14- Ernest M. Chamberlain, Letters to his wife from Fort Sill, December 13-26, 1942

15- Fay Barney Chamberlain, Letters to Ernest M. Chamberlain, December 10 & 11 & 20, 1942

Merry Christmas!

Merry Christmas!

and Merry Christmas!

Merry Christmas!

and Merry Christmas again!

 

27- Fay Barney Chamberlain: Dating and Marriage.

The Old Mill was the location of a University of Utah Sorority dance in Spring of 1937

The love story of Fay Barney and Ernest Chamberlain began in the Spring of 1937, by my best estimate, this was on Friday, March 26. However, whatever the exact day was, it began at the Old Mill.

The rustic old walls of the one time paper mill were decorated and turned into a romantic setting for a big band dance. A University of Utah sorority sponsored this as a girls choice.1

Both Ernest and Fay would later express their belief that their love story and eventual marriage and family was meant to be, perhaps even pre-ordained in the heavens. If this is true, the angels assigned the project of getting them together for this romantic first date had their work cut out for them.

The dance at South High School

Ernest and Fay both lived within the boundaries of the Granite Stake. Their fathers, Harry Chamberlain and Archie Barney were acquainted, as they served together on the stake genealogical committee.2 Ernest certainly had noticed the attractive Fay Barney from a distance at Stake conferences and activities.

South High School

In 1935, Fay Barney was a senior at South High School. One of Fay’s classmates invited Ernest to a girl’s dance. It was a custom at the time to dance the first and last dance with your date, but have the schedule of dances arranged to trade with other dance partners. Ernest’s date had most of the dances traded with her friends. It was a fun evening. Ernest was laughing and joking with all his dance partners and got along swell with all of girls, except one. Her name was Fay Barney.1

SHAG Girls Dance, 1935

Fay was beautiful and always dressed in the latest styles. Her family seemed well to do. Ernest apparently had formed the opinion that she was just too sophisticated for him. This combined with the fact that he was attracted to her, left him speechless. Also, for this dance, he “felt he had two left feet.”1

Fay was naturally quiet. She wondered about the change that came over Ernest when it was her turn to dance. Neither one of them said a word through the entire dance. Finally, the music ended and they broke the silence with a polite, “Thank you.”

It would be about two years before they spoke again.3

Dating in the 1930s

The dating experiences of Ernest and Fay teach us a lot about their personalities and dating customs of their time. Dating in the 1930s was much different than today (2020). Ernest wrote stories of his general dating experience. Fay, on the other hand, left us a box full of letters, photos, mementos and gum wrappers.

Dancing was very popular in the 1930s and all dances came with a schedule. Different partners would trade dances at the appropriate time. It was a great way to get to know a lot of different people. There were various types of dances, waltzes, foxtrots, swing etc. Male and female partners actually touched each other when they danced and maybe enjoyed a conversation. Coordinating your rhythm with a partner could be challenging for some.  

In high school and early college years males and females would date a wide variety of partners. They may chose a different partner every date. The point was to have a good time together and to meet different people. After the date was over no commitment was assumed or expected. 

When a relationship became more serious the boy would ask his girl to wear his class ring or pin. This would signal that they were going steady. They then dated each other exclusively until they broke up.

Engagement came with a diamond ring and a date for a wedding day.

Letters to Fay Barney, 1935

Fay Barney, 1936

Fay graduated from High School in the class of 1935. She started her studies at the University of Utah in the fall. She loved the summers when she could stay with her favorite country cousins. Fay was very popular with the boys as we learn from the letters she saved.

She often stayed with her cousin Eva and her Uncle George and Aunt Jeanette Adams Williams who lived in Treasureton a small town in southern Idaho near Preston. Fay and her family went to Treasureton on July 4, 1935.2

When she got there, she wrote to a boy friend in Utah. On July 9, 1935, James Kippen from Woods Cross, Utah wrote a letter back to her in Idaho. “Tell your aunt Nettie and cousin Eva Hi.” He then warned her to be careful about those young farmers (in Idaho) or she may end up a farmer’s wife, and that wouldn’t be so good. The letter was ended by saying he had to get up at 4 am to irrigate the onions. Signed: “With Love, Jim”4

In Idaho she met a boy from a neighboring farm named Don. They had a good time together. He took her horse back riding every day. Don told Fay he would take her home so that she could stay longer after her family went back to Salt Lake. They were together so much her cousins teased them by writing a little rhyme about them.3

Varr Alder

Fay went to a dance in Preston, Idaho where she met Varr Alder. She liked him and spent most of the dance with him. This made Don very upset. He told Eva to give Fay a message. To make sure Fay got the message he passed her a hand written note: “Fay, I want to see you and talk to you for fifteen minutes alone between 10 and 11 o’clock. If you don’t come it will be quite evident that you don’t want to see me anymore ever.”4

Apparently, Fay didn’t show.

On July 25, 1935, Varr Alder wrote to Fay in SLC from Preston Idaho. He asked if she got home last Saturday night (the 20th). He didn’t know if Don would take her home or not, considering the way he was acting on Thursday (the 18th).4

Fay speaking of this event many years later said: “Don got mad and wouldn’t take me home (to Salt Lake), so therefore I had to hitchhike a ride with a milk man to somewhere.” She couldn’t remember the details of how she finally made it all the way home.3 However, ten days later on July 30, 1935, Archie Barney recorded in his journal: “George W. (Fay’s Uncle), Fay, Eva and Dora came down from Treasurton.”2

In a letter of August 14, 1935, Varr wrote to Fay and told her about his exciting life in Idaho. While drinking he was racing his car and when it got up to 65 mph his tire blew. He and his passenger had minor injuries but his car was totaled. He told her he was coming to Salt Lake between Christmas and New Years. “If I come, can we celebrate in a big way?” he asked.  “I can be good if I have to”, he assured her.4

Letters to Fay Barney 1936

In February,1936, Roger McGuire was a young man living away in Wisconsin taking business classes. He wrote Fay a very nice letter thanking her for the box of beautiful chocolates that she made and sent him for Christmas. He ended the letter, “hoping you will write to me about yourself. Your old friend, Roger.”4

Howard “Howdy” Patterson

Howard Patterson (Howdy), Earl Pusey, Bob Booth and Loyal Nideen (Sandy), were her friends in Salt Lake City. Charlette,”Charlie” was a girl friend who seemed to be the social director of this group. Fay’s close girl friends where Phyllis who would write notes to Fay while waiting in class for the bell to ring,4 Lois Bouman a “down to earth” friend who lived near her home,6 and sorority sister Norma Hamilton.2

“Howdy” was very interested in her and kept up to date on her activities. He sent her a letter when she was in Eureka on June 19, 1936. “You don’t seem to be having a bad time, parties, shows and dances”, he wrote in his letter.4

Eureka UT was a small town nestled in a mountain valley south-west of Utah Lake about 70 miles from SLC. Fay often stayed there with her cousin Audrey and her Aunt Jennie Rae Barney Humphery and Uncle Cleve Humphery.

Fay’s boy friend during this visit to Eureka was Henry.5 She met Henry Wall in 1933.4 Fay thought he was “real neat” and he was her first love. Henry’s girlfriend Dora was not happy when Fay came to town.3 Archie brought Fay home from Eureka on June 22.

On July 10, Fay, with her mother and father, traveled again to Treasureton, Idaho. They left early in the morning and visited the Ag. College in Logan along their way. There was a heavy storm north of Preston. They celebrated Fay’s eighteenth Birthday with ice cream and cake at Aunt Nettie’s on the 11th. The families attended church together on Sunday the 12th, then drove back to SLC that evening.2

Varr saw Fay when they were in Idaho and on July 16 wrote to her in SLC. He said, “Forgive me for the way I treated you, will you? Love Varr” Another letter from Varr on August 14 asked her when she would be back in Idaho. He enticed her with the following line. “Do you even drink? If you do you should have been with me Saturday night. Boy! oh Boy!!!!!! Talk about a lot of fun.” He then explained how fun it was waking up the next morning at 5 am at a different location and a different car. No one could remember switching cars or where the other car was.4

Fay, apparently, never wrote to him again. The gum wrappers tell us that she never developed real interest for any of the Idaho boys.5

The mystery of the gum wrappers

Fay’s gum wrappers. Each one contained a note.

In Fay’s box of mementos, there were dozens of dance schedules, some letters, and about twenty empty gum wrappers. These wrappers of Wrigley’s Double Mint Chewing Gum were folded with the foil placed neatly back into the paper cover.

Why did she save them?

Eventually, I opened one and found it had a note inside. In fact, they all had a note inside! Each one had the name of a boy, a date and a location or event. Since mint gum is an obvious breath freshener, I realized that I had found my mother’s record of every time she kissed a boy. The record covered a 16 month period from February 6, 1935 to June 27, 1936.5

Barney Family vacation at Fish lake, Utah

Dean, Carol, Livonia, Archie, Fay and Ellen Barney. Fay rowing boat at Fish Lake.

On July 18, 1936 the Barney family Archie, Livonia, Fay, Ellen, Dean and Carol and even my great grandma Agnes Adams headed south for a two week vacation. After visiting relatives and historic sites along the way, they arrived at Fish Lake on the afternoon of the 20th. They then went together for a boat ride on the lake.2

Doctor A. A. Andersen, his wife Dora and their family were also at the lake. Dr Andersen was the Barney family doctor and close friend. They were there with their two daughters and son, Andy.2

Andy Andersen was another one of Fay’s boy friends.4

They had fish for breakfast every morning. The three fishermen in the group were Dean Barney, Dr. Andersen and Livonia Barney. In two days out fishing Livonia, (my dear little grandmother Barney) caught the most fish. She caught seven, each 12 to 13 inches long. Dean caught 3 fish, one of them was 18 inches, and Dr. Andersen caught the largest fish which was three feet long and weighed 15 pounds.2

On Saturday, August 1 the five Andersens and six Barneys went for a swim in the lake. The water was very cold. Dora and Andy Andersen swam 600 feet out in the lake. In the evening, Archie drove the Andersen children and the Barney Children to a dance where the entire group had a fine time.2

The next morning the two families had a hotcake breakfast together. Then the Barney’s waved good bye to the Andersens and headed toward Salt Lake City.2

More Letters to Fay, 1936

Letters to Fay Barney

When Fay got to Fish Lake, she wrote to Howdy. On July 29, Howdy sent his response to Fay at Fish Lake. “When are you coming home?” he asked. “You come home and I see you once, if I am lucky, and you are gone again.

Before he got her letter from Fish Lake, he went to Preston, Idaho to she if she was there. He told her in his letter that he went to the dance in Preston, but didn’t see any of her boy friends there. Howdy and Carl didn’t know who would be at the dance or what scene might unfold, Carl chose to stay in the car and sleep until the dance was over.4

Howard was quite possessive of Fay, and her letters contained some not so subtle hints that they were not a pair. He ended his letter with a complaint. “You ended Carl’s letter ‘Love Fay, but mine, you just ended ‘Fay’…  Signed: “Love Howdy”4

Andy Andersen who was still at Fish Lake, wrote to Fay on August 4. He told her they expected to be back in SLC on Monday evening (the 10th), and hoped perhaps they could go to the Old Mill on Tuesday. He missed swimming with her in the lake and wished she was there. Andy then asked: “Will you be ready to wear my pin when I get back? You know I want you to, don’t you?” “Hope to hear from you soon, Love Andy”4

He wrote again two days later to acknowledge a letter he received from her, and told her he would return Archie’s cat that was left at the lake when he got back on Tuesday or Wednesday. He hoped he would be able to see her then.4

The Engagement

Fay Barney and Andy Andersen

Dr. Andersen and his family had car trouble and did not get back on Tuesday. However, on Wednesday Fay went to a show with Andy and on Thursday August 13 they went on a swimming party.2

Archie Barney’s family and other relatives had a splendid picnic at Liberty Park on Sunday the 16th. Archie wrote in his journal: “Dr Anderson and his family was supposed to be with us but they turned us down, except Andy. He stayed with us.”2

I believe this picnic was meant to be their engagement announcement, but it tuned out to be the time their short engagement ended. Fay shared the following memory with Deanna Chamberlain Grant in 2008:

I was engaged to Dr. Andersen’s son, Andy. I knew that I wasn’t going to marry him. Dr. Anderson just loved me, too. When Andy spoke with his dad about marriage, Dr. Andersen said, ‘You can not get married now. You’ve got to go to school and become a doctor.’ So Andy had to break the sad news to me. Andy, broken-hearted, left home and his dad was unhappy about what he had done.6

“Free as a breeze”

On Saturday September 5, Audrey called the Barneys and wanted Fay and her friend Lois to come to Eureka for the Labor Day celebration. The 9th was Fay’s mother’s birthday and she was suppose to come home sometime that day. Andy Andersen brought his monopoly game over to the Barney’s and played with Ellen, Dean and Carol until mid-night, but Fay never came. Fay finally got home the next evening at 10 pm.2

Larry Carter met Fay’s family when they came to Eureka. “I sure like your family”, he wrote on October 27. “Your daddy is swell and your mother too. She is certainly congenial”. He then joked that she should watch her sister (Ellen) or he will be dating her. He made up for it by giving Fay glowing praise for her beauty and wonderful personality. “I certainly had a lot of fun with you in Eureka on Labor Day, Fay….I had more fun down there in that short time than I have ever had”, he wrote.4

Earl Pusey

After her engagement ended she tried to reconnect with some of her old friends. Howard’s possessiveness had made it hard for her to establish a relationship with others of her group who she liked more. She sent a Christmas present to Earl Pusey and also wrote to others.

On January 7, 1937 Earl wrote to Fay in SLC from Des Moine Iowa. He was working for Associated Press and expected to move to Denver or back to SLC soon. Earl thanked her and Lois for the grand present and talked about the old gang Sandy, Howd, Bob and Charlie. “In your note you mentioned something about being free as a breeze. Boy am I glad. I just hope you stay that way until I come back, I might have a chance after all.”4

Loyal Niden (Sandy) was working in Palms, California when he wrote to Fay on February 28, 1937. “Char told me you were planning to write to Pety. Sooo, I thought if you wanted to write to Pete, maybe you would write to me”. She very pleasantly surprised him when she did. He told her it was a shame they had not gone together on a date, and hoped to have the privilege sometime. “I never asked you for a date out of respect for Howard,” he said.4

Ernest Chamberlain and Jack Chamberlin

Jack Chamberlin, 1937

Jack Chamberlin and Ernest went to East High School and became very close friends during their first quarter at the University of Utah. They got together when ever they could, evenings, weekends and on campus. They went on double dates together almost every weekend.1

On their first double date Ernest went out with Helen Augustine and Jack’s girl was also named Helen. Since they were both named Chamberlain, (with a minor spelling difference), they thought it would be fun to always go with girls with the same name. It was an interesting challenge. Therefore, most of their dates would have the same first name, or twins with the same last name.1

The bet

One day Jack jokingly bet Ernest that he couldn’t go three months without kissing a girl. Ernest, caught up in their animated conversation, bet he could. Jack quickly replied, “You’re on!” Ernest immediately realized his stupid mistake and kicked himself all afternoon for his big mouth.1

Then an idea struck.

Ernest bought a chain with small unusual links and made a fine looking chain-link bracelet.  He fastened it on his left wrist. It was a great conversation piece. He used it to tell the girl about the bet he had made, and that if he ever did kiss a girl, she would get the bracelet. This produced a psychological effect which made the following months of dating most interesting.

There were three basic responses: 1- Girls not interested in kissing could relax and have an enjoyable evening. 2- Some girls felt the evening would not be complete without at least a good night kiss. In this case, Ernest might tease these girls with a near kiss, but then stop without forfeiting the bet. 3- Then there were girls who may normally skip a kiss, or not, but in either case they saw the challenge. Their inner drive for conquest would set in and they would strive to win the bracelet.

One day the University put on a “Blind Date Ball”.  Jack and Ernest applied and soon received the name of their blind date. Ernest described his date as “a cute little blond with a good healthy endowment of the body features that make up an attractive figure”. In fewer words, she was smokin’ hot! The last dance was a slow waltz, and at this time it became obvious to Ernest that this girl fell into category three.

After the dance they went out for ice cream and then for a ride. Jack was driving his folks car. He soon noticed there was an aggressive gal snuggling in the back seat with Ernest. Jack’s prospect for a win was looking good.

Ernest felt his temperature rise. He could only pray they would get to her home soon – Jack took his time. Finally, they got to her home and by a tread the bracelet had survived.

At the end of three months, Ernest thought someone he really liked should get the bracelet. He finally decided it should be Bernadine, Jack’s sister. She was really a choice gal and they went out on several dates.  This might have become a serious relationship. However, they soon decided to stop going together as her mother was a staunch Catholic. They both knew it wouldn’t work out in the end.1

Playing the piano in Kingsbury Hall

Kingsbury Hall, University of Utah, 1937

Fay had an amazing talent as she could play the piano by ear. She had taken a few piano lessons but never learned to read music because as soon as she heard a popular song she could play it. She would often go to Kingsbury Hall and play the piano for hours. Fraternities would invite her to play for them and the group would sing together and have a great time.2

Piano room, Kingsbury Hall, 1937

Fay’s friend, Loyal Nideen, wrote in February 1937: “You and Char do have quite a swell time and interest in the U of U’s daily happenings. Three cheers for both of you. I’ll bet the place couldn’t get along without you two charming ladies. No kidding, I mean it.”4

Horseback riding

One of Fay’s favorite classes was Horseback riding lessons for PE. The military owned the horses and Ernest Chamberlain was in the ROTC. After class, Fay brought her horse back to the stable. It was Ernest’s job to brush the horses until they cooled down.6

When he saw her, he thought of asking her out. Jack knew a girl named Fay, and Ernest thought he might need to make a name match with Jack’s date.3 However, when he mentioned this interest to his ROTC friends they discouraged him. “You don’t want to get to know her. You wouldn’t be able to provide for her in the way she is accustomed”, they advised.6

Meeting at the Library

Fay Barny and Norma Hamilton, 1937

Norma Hamilton and Fay were going to Kingsbury Hall but changed their minds and decided instead to go to the university library. When Ernest came in, he saw Fay sitting with their common friend, Norma.  Fay was beautiful but sophisticated. “Too sophisticated for my blood”, he thought.3

Jack Chamberlin and Ruth Olsen came in later and joined them. The group of them met together several times after that.1

Ernest and Fay have very different memories of their meetings in the library.

Ernest remembered the painful experience at South High two years earlier. Now, however, he could see this fashionable beauty having difficulty in her chemistry class and needed help with some math problems.1 This help, he could nobly provide.

Fay remembers a social goofball who took her favorite bracelet and teased her by saying he was going to give it to his sister. Fay said, “OK, you can have it”. This spoiled his fun so he gave it back.3

An unconventional dating style

Ernest and Jack had a fun but unconventional dating style. They often would tell their dates to prepare a box lunch and to bring swimming suites and tennis rackets to be ready for any spontaneous idea that might come up.1 Many years later, Fay said she thought Ernest “was handsome and fun but a little bit silly at times”.6

One afternoon Jack and Ruth said, “Let’s go to the Gem Theater Saturday night”.

“That sounds great”, Ernest replied.

“How about asking Fay? She seems like a swell girl.”

The South High dance came to his mind and Ernest explained why Fay would not be his choice.  Nevertheless, they persisted on the idea, after all, this was not a dance. Ernest decided to give it a try. He was quite sure, and hopeful, she would not accept.1

Later in the day Ernest located her in the library. He sat down and they chatted for a while. Then finally he got around to say, “How would you like to go with me to the Gem Theater Saturday night and throw popcorn off the balcony?”

Fay looked a little startled and said, “Yes, I guess so.”3

Stood up

Ernest went skiing the next Saturday morning. When he got home, his sister Lois told him that Fay had called. She said her mother was sick and therefore she could not go tonight.

Ernest was not too surprised. There was a dance at Union Hall at the U. that Saturday night and she probably got a better offer. Nevertheless, he was upset to be stood up and now he was without a date for tonight. “No sweat,” he thought, “I can call Ruth Shelton”. He did and she accepted.

This date was on a Saturday during the winter of 1936-37. Archie Barney’s daily journal almost always recorded each member of his family’s activities and who was ill and who was fine. Livonia suffered with anxiety and was ill quite often. She was very ill through November and December and also on several weekends during January and February. According to Fay’s father’s journal everything she told Ernest was true.

Nevertheless, I am skeptical. I am not convinced that her mother’s illness prevented her from going on an important date. I believe there was a tremendous inner conflict going on within her. Her acceptance of Ernest’s offer surprised her as much as it did him. Like Ernest, she also had second thoughts. She was unaware that she was making one of the most important decisions of her life.

There is something about making a choice that instantly brings understanding. Shortly after she hung up the phone, the right course became clear and the significance became known. She had made the wrong choice and she knew it.

The dance at the Old Mill

Fay had stayed home with her mother where she could be greatly helpful. However, she now regretted that she cancelled the date with Ernest. As time passed, she knew he would never ask her out again.

Fay Barney and Ernest Chamberlain Easter Sunday, March 28, 1937

In the 1930s the man would always ask the woman for the date. However, there was one exception. Once a year there was a girls choice dance. Fay’s sorority was having one at the Old Mill near the mouth of Big Cottonwood Canyon. This was her only chance. Fay called Ernest and asked him to the dance.

Ernest swallowed his pride and accepted. “Inspite of myself, I had a wonderful evening in the romantic atmosphere”.1

They then began to hit if off, enjoy each other’s company and get better acquainted. Their first photo together was taken on Easter Sunday March 28, 1937.

Archie and Livonia Barney were on a trip to California and returned after April 5.2 Fay invited Ernest to Sunday dinner to meet her parents in April. Fay’s mother was sure to let Ernest know that she had been ill on the night of the broken date.1

The dance at the Old Mill was the first of many enjoyable romantic outings together which included the Officer’s Ball at Camp Williams, and the Junior Prom.

Lois Chamberlain, unknown lady, Fay Barney, Ernest Chamberlain, Norma Hamilton, Harry Bachmann, U of U campus.

Livonia Barney

Livonia Barney, Ernest Chamberlain, Fay Barney

Ernest told a story about Fay’s mother Livonia when he and Fay were dating. He said she was very finicky about lint on clothing. Often when Ernest came in the house to pick up Fay, Livonia would see a piece of lint or a hair on his jacket and she would pick it off. This was rather embarrassing.

One day, before coming to visit Fay, Ernest got a spool of white tread and put it in his suit jacket pocket with just a bit of white tread showing on the outside. True to form, when Ernest went in the house Livonia spotted the little piece of white tread.

“She started pulling and pulling and pulling, and I thought she was going to die. I could just see she thought she was going to have a sleeve or something off my jacket. Finally, I started laughing and showed her the spool of thread. She never took another piece of lint off my jacket again.”7

Summer 1937

Ernest M. Chamberlain, University of Utah graduation.

Ernest graduated in the Spring of 1937. Summer was full of fun activities. On July 5 Ernest, Fay, Jack and Ruth took a picnic lunch and and headed up Parley’s Canyon toward Morgan.2,3 They went swimming at a hot springs in Northern Utah. On the way home they all went to a dance at Lagoon. The girls objected at first because their wet hair was not dance worthy.1

On July 11 all of Fay’s friends threw a surprise 19th birthday party for her. As it turned out, the surprise was on them. They didn’t know about Ernest. Howard was devastated.6

The unemployment rate that summer was above 10% and rising. By the end of the year it would hit 12.5%. Ernest applied for several jobs in accounting but did not have any success. The University placement bureau referred him a Job at S. H. Kress Company to train for store management. He got the Job in July.

It paid $20.00 per week and he felt great to get the position. However, the hours were long. Six days a week he worked in the stock room for various departments from 7 am to 6 pm. In the evenings three days a week he assisted in decorating the windows and counters from 7 pm to 10 or 10:30.1

Christmas Eve 1937

Ernest and Fay were happy and comfortable together. He admired her talents, especially her excellent sewing abilities. They shared religious beliefs and often went to church activities together in addition to the double dates with Jack and Ruth. Ernest soon decided Fay was the girl he wanted to marry.

Fay’s birthstone ruby ring

Fay wore a ruby birthstone ring. One time when Ernest was admiring her ring he “forgot” to give it back to her. He returned it the next day with his apologies. He was therefore able to get her ring size and planned to surprise her by replacing the ruby ring with a diamond.1

It was Christmas Eve at the Barney home. The stockings were hung over the fireplace waiting for Santa’s visit. Archie had placed one there for Ernest.2

The Barney family had gone to bed and they were now alone in the living room. The room enjoyed a soft glow from the lights of the Christmas tree. Ernest held Fay’s hand. He gently slipped off the ruby ring and then casually replaced it with a diamond. Fay didn’t notice the switch.

Ernest anxiously awaited her reaction. He became tense as the minutes ticked by. She was still unaware of the diamond ring on her finger. Finally, Fay looked down at her hand and let out a scream!. “She gave me a big kiss. Then she jumped up and ran into the into the bedroom to awaken and tell her folks.”1

Ernest didn’t hear an answer, but her reaction seemed satisfactory.

Married June 29, 1938

Fay agreed to marry Ernest on one condition. That was that he quit his Job at S. H. Kress Company. She was concerned about the long hours and feared she would never see him. She had faith in Ernest’s ability and education and that he could get a better job as an accountant.

Ernest later said that her faith was greater than the times warranted.3 Nevertheless, Ernest loved Fay and believed that it was the right thing to do. Both Fay and Ernest’s parents supported their decision. He quit his job before their wedding.1

Wedding reception line: Norma Hamilton, Lois Chamberlain, Ruth Olsen, Ellen Barney. Fay Barney Chamberlain, Ernest Chamberlain and Jack Chamberlin.

On June 29, 1938, Fay and Ernest were married in the Salt Lake Temple. They had a wedding reception at the Barney home that evening. After the reception, they checked into the Temple Square hotel for their wedding night.1

Ernest worked odd jobs while he looked for employment. They stayed with Ernest’s parents for a few weeks until they found an apartment. They moved to their first home at 553 East, Second South in July and a few months later moved to 244 1/2 South Second East.8

Ernest and Fay’s first Apartment

Ernest and Fay’s second apartment

Idaho Falls, Idaho

Ernest and Idaho Falls home, January 1939.

In January, 1939, Ernest got a job as a bookkeeper with Pacific Fruit and Produce Company. It required that they move to Idaho Falls, Idaho. Fay and Ernest were happy there. Betty Morley and Paul Ahlstrom were there neighbors and they became good friends. When Jack and Ruth came to visit them and saw how happy they were living together in their little cottage in Idaho, they decided to get married also.3

The workforce at Pacific Fruit consisted of an office manager, who always smoked a cigar, several salesmen, an accountant and Ernest. Unfortunately, after a while, economic problems flared up once more and they had to reduce their staff. They let Ernest go.1

Fay told their experience after losing the job at Pacific Fruit:

“The few months between jobs at Pacific Fruit and Montgomery Ward, we had a period of starving. We were very poor and lived on potatoes and onions. I learned how to prepare and cook onions many different ways to try to add favor and variety. We went to visit Betty and Paul, I could see steak and all sorts of good food on the counters. Betty would offer us cake. I was very grateful, but longed for the meat all the while I was eating cake.”6

Finally, Ernest got a job at the Montgomery Ward store in Idaho Falls. He was in charge of the paint and wallpaper department. This was likely a seasonal position that would end after the holidays. At the end of the year there was a reduction of force and Ernest was out of a job once again.8 Fay was now expecting their first child so they decided it was best to return to Salt Lake City.

Ernest and Fay 1939

Fay Barney Chamberlain, Archie F. Barney, Livonia Barney, Dean Barney, Carol Barney, Ellen Barney and Chico.

Ernest Martin Chamberlain, Jr. born March 20, 1940

Fay was expecting their first child in March and the struggling couple were welcomed into the Barney home. On January 3, 1940 Archie wrote, “We expect Fay and Ernest to come from Idaho Falls soon.” They met Fay at the station on January 6 and Ernest came on January 11. “Ernest and Fay staying with us for a while.2

On January 17, Ernest had some work with an accountant down town for a few days. Fay got to see Dr. Andersen for an examination on the 23rd. Jack and Ruth Chamberlin had dinner at the Barney’s on the 24th. On Feb 1, Ernest went to Henager’s (business school) all day where he apparently began a course on short hand. That evening, he spent two hours at an Army meeting. Ernest was expecting to go with Mr. Teal to Roosevelt to see about some work, but Mr. Teal called on Feb. 8.  He said the position was filled.2

Fay and Ernest Chamberlain and baby Martin in front of Barney Home.

On March 19, Archie came home from work early in the afternoon as Fay was not well. Archie, Livonia and Ernest took her to the hospital where she was admitted at 5:20 pm. They stayed quite late, Ernest stayed at the hospital all night with Fay. Archie and Livonia were worried and didn’t sleep well that night.2

The next morning, Dr. Andersen took Fay into the delivery room. He sent Ernest into another room to rest. The baby was born at 10:55 am, March 20, 1940. The father and the grandparents were exhausted, but mother and baby were doing fine.2

Three apartments and a job

Ernest was taking classes at the business college and Grandma Livonia Barney was having fun taking care of her first grandchild. But it was not an ideal situation for a young married couple to be staying with the parents.

On April 22, 1940 Archie took Fay out to look at three or four apartments. On April 23, Archie wrote: “We rented an apartment at 89 M Street for Fay and Ernest.”2

Ernest found a job at Nelson Ricks Creamery in August 1940 and in September they moved into the Olive Apartments at 24 South, Third East. They moved again to the York Apartments 310 South, Seventh East in July, 1941.8

Rumors of war

Ernest and Fay planned a party for a large group of their new friends on November 15, 1941. Ernest went to great lengths to be sure their guests had a good time. For one game, he blew out an egg and painted the shell like a football. The object of the game was use straws to blow the football through the opponents goal posts. The seven couples had a delicious dinner and seemed to have an exceptionally good time.9

The family was happy. The job at Nelson Ricks Creamery was going well. It was the first job since Ernest graduated from the U of U that lasted over one year. However, clouds of war were forming that could change everything. On November 17, Ernest heard a news report that a German merchant ship was captured by US ships. It was flying an American flag in an attempt to run the British blockage. “And so it goes,” Ernest wrote, “each day getting a little nearer to that which seems inevitable.”9

Ernest was right, in three weeks the nation would be at war.

To be continued…..

28- Ernest M. Chamberlain after Pearl Harbor

29- Ernest and Fay Chamberlain Family During WWII, 1942

© Copyright Dennis D. Chamberlain, The Chamberlain Story, 2020. Unauthorized use and/or duplication of the written content of this site without express and written permission from the author and owner is strictly prohibited. Excerpts and links may be used, provided that credit is given to Dennis D. Chamberlain and direction to  www.thechamberlainstory.com.

References:

1- Ernest M. Chamberlain autobiography

2- Archie F. Barney, A Collection of Barney Journals transcribed by Deanna Chamberlain Grant and others

3- Life of Fay and Ernest Chamberlain through WW2, part 1, on CD. Recorded in England June 25, 1994 by Lyle Brent Chamberlain.

4- Fay’s box of letters 1933-37

5- Fay Barney notes written on gum wrappers, 1935-36

6- Fay Barney experiences told to her daughter, Deanna Chamberlain Grant in 2008. Recorded in Barney Journals.

7- Lara Chamberlain, Conversation with Grandma and Grandpa (Fay and Ernest Chamberlain) From About 2008.

8- Ernest M. Chamberlain, Statement of Personal History (Approval Expires October 1, 1953) Two different undated statements with some errors and variation. One cosigned by Thomas E Shaughnessy, the other by Kirk L. Brimley.

9- Ernest Chamberlain, “Year Book” November 14, 1941 – August 16, 1942